Organic Chicken at Whole Foods - Rosie vs. Mary

Normally I buy Mary's Air Chilled Organic jumbo packs of chicken pieces. This time, I grabbed Rosie's Organic chicken leg packs, and unfortunately I was disappointed. The texture of the Rosie's was rubbery, even though I baked it using the same oil, the same tempurature. The taste was also slightly less "chicken-y" than Mary's.